Pennsylvania denies AI cyber charter school application

Artificial intelligence
Pennsylvania determined Unbound Academy failed to meet several state requirements for cyber charter schools and did not provide enough evidence to support its bold academic claims. (Getty Images)

Sign up for Chalkbeat Philadelphia’s free newsletter to keep up with news on the city’s public school system.

Pennsylvania’s Department of Education issued a scathing denial on Wednesday for a controversial cyber charter school built around artificial intelligence.

The department determined the application for Unbound Academy “provided no evidence of sustainable support” for the school and said it “lacks the capability, in terms of both support and planning, to provide comprehensive learning experiences to students” and “fails to substantiate that it will serve as a model for other public schools,” among other concerns.

“There is no compelling evidence that Unbound Academic’s proposed programs will enable students to meet academic standards,” the denial reads. The application “failed to provide even a list of courses that would be offered to students.”

The founders behind Unbound Academy promised the school would educate students twice as fast by giving them two hours of individually crafted lesson plans and academic work designed by AI tutoring software. In their model, teachers would shift from their traditional roles to instead become guides tasked with motivating and supporting students rather than doing the instructional work of teaching.

Founder MacKenzie Price told Chalkbeat she believes the model will revolutionize education.

Pennsylvania’s Interim Acting Secretary of Education Angela Fitterer determined this week that Unbound’s promises were largely without sufficient proof and did not provide adequate plans to serve students with disabilities or other vulnerable student populations.

“The artificial intelligence instructional model being proposed by this school is untested and fails to demonstrate how the tools, methods, and providers would ensure alignment to Pennsylvania academic standards,” the denial letter reads.

The denial letter further assails Unbound Academy’s application as failing to “reflect an understanding of cyber charter school finances.”

The state also said the school demonstrated little interest from Pennsylvania families and submitted no petitions or letters of support from parents, students, or educators.

Pennsylvania teachers’ unions celebrated the denial on Wednesday.

“There is no way that two hours of AI-guided learning in core subjects could replace direct instruction from a certified teacher or meet state academic standards,” Pennsylvania State Education Association President Aaron Chapin said in a statement.

A spokesperson for Price, Unbound Academy, and its affiliated private schools did not immediately respond to a request for comment on Wednesday.

Unbound can appeal the state’s decision within 30 days.

Carly Sitrin is the bureau chief for Chalkbeat Philadelphia. Contact Carly at csitrin@chalkbeat.org.

The Latest

Community leaders are divided about what type of intervention is needed.

The current version of the legislation is a far cry from what bill sponsors envisioned.

One building will become a preschool center. Another will be the new home of an existing middle and high school.

Students who complete one of the state’s new graduation pathways will also be eligible for interviews with large companies.

The council asked for nearly $300 million more for early childhood education, which has emerged as a major sticking point in recent budget negotiations.

There are 11 candidates running for three seats, as teen voters gear up to vote for the first time in the local school board election.